Compare Whynter ICM-15LS vs ICM-200LS vs ICM-201SB What’s the Difference?

If you are deciding between Whynter ICM-15LS, ICM-200LS and ICM-201SB ice cream maker, the comparison below that shows you the difference and similarities between them will help you make an informed decision.

image from Whynter official site infomercial

Difference:
Bowl Material:
The ICM-15LS and ICM-200LS come with an Aluminum bowl whereas the ICM-201SB included bowl material is Stainless Steel.
Whynter also makes stainless steel bowls for the ICM-15LS and ICM-200LS that can be purchased separately.

Check ICM-201SB Price at Amazon

Control Panel and Display:
The control panel on the three models are a bit different.
The ICM-15LS has 3 buttons:Power,Start/Stop,Timer; a small LCD display to show time and temperature(alternate); 2 indicator lights: Mixing Indicator and Cooling Indicator. It does not have a separate button that allows you to select the mode you want. When you press START/STOP button, it begins mixing immediately and cooling starts 2 minutes later, during the ice cream making process, you can press START/STOP button to turn on/off the churning function. The cooling function remains on. Not as intuitive as the ICM-200LS and ICM-201SB that feature a Menu button to choose between 3 modes.

image from Whynter official site infomercial

The ICM-200LS has five buttons: Power, Start/Pause, Menu, Time+, Time-; a LCD display to show time and modes: Ice Cream, Cooling Only, Mixing Only. But no temperature readout.

image from Whynter official site infomercial

The ICM-201SB has 4 buttons: Power, Start/Pause, Menu, Timer; a LCD display to show time, internal temperature, and modes: Ice Cream, Cooling, Mixing.

image from Whynter official site infomercial

Timer:
On the ICM-15LS, the operation time you can select are: 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 minutes, the preset time is 60 minutes, pressing the Timer button will lower the timer by 10 minute increment.
On the ICM-200LS, the operation time you can select is 5 to 60 minutes, you can press the Time+ button to increase the operation time or press the Time– button to decrease operation time by one minute increment.
On the ICM-201SB, the operation time you can select is 5 to 60 minutes by one minute increment, you can press the Timer button to increase the operation time starting from 5 minutes and up to 60 minutes.

Extended Cooling Feature:
All of them have the Extended Cooling Feature. If the appliance is not turned off in 10 minutes, they automatically enter into a Extended Cooling Function to prevent the mixture from melting, this function help keep the yummy frozen when you are away.
For ICM-15LS, when the set operation time has elapsed, the cooling function continues to run without churning function for 10 minutes in every other 10 minutes for a total of one hour.
For ICM-200LS, in this function, the compressor will come on and the display will flash
“COOL” for a ten-minute cycle for a total of one hour.
For ICM-201SB, in this function, the compressor will come on in six-minute cycles for two
hours.

Check ICM-200LS Price at Amazon

Blade Design:
The blade design on these 3 Whynter are a bit different from each other.

Appearance:
This is a noticeable difference that you can easily find out. The ICM-201SB has upright housing, its footprint is smaller and takes up less space than ICM-15LS and ICM-200LS.

Capacity:
The ICM-200LS and ICM-201SB have a capacity of 2.1 quarts while the ICM-15LS is 1.6 quarts.

Power:
The power specs of ICM-200LS and ICM-201SB are: 110/120V 60Hz, 180 watts, 3 amps.
The power specs of ICM-15LS are: 110/120V 60Hz, 150 watts,2.4 amps

There are also difference on dimension and weight, and some similarities between them, read the comparison table below to learn more details:

Check ICM-15LS Price at Amazon

Model ICM-201SB ICM-200LS ICM-15LS
Type Ice Cream Maker Ice Cream Maker Ice Cream Maker
Power 110/120V 60Hz, 180 watts,3 amps 110/120V 60Hz, 180 watts, 3 amps, 110/120V 60Hz, 150 watts,2.4 amps
Capacity 2.1 quarts (2 liter) 2.1 quarts (2 liter) 1.6 quarts(1.5 liter)
Housing Stainless Steel Stainless Steel Stainless Steel
Bowl Stainless Steel Aluminum Aluminum
Blade BPA-Free Plastic BPA-Free Plastic BPA-Free Plastic
Adjustable Speed No No No
Display LCD LCD LCD
Temperature Range -0.4°F to -31°F / -18°C to -35°C -0.4°F to -31°F / -18°C to -35°C -0.4°F to -31°F / -18°C to -35°C
Adjustable Temperature No No No
Temperature Readout Yes No No
Modes
  • Ice Cream
  • Cooling only
  • Mixing only
  • Ice Cream
  • Cooling only
  • Mixing only
  • Ice Cream
  • Cooling only
Extended Cooling Function Yes Yes Yes
Including Scoop Yes Yes Yes
Weight 24.25 lbs 24.25 lbs 27 lbs
Dimensions 12.5″ W x 10.75″ D x 14.25″ H 16.75″ W x 11.25″ D x 10.25″ H 18.5″ W x 11″L x 10″
Warranty 1 Year Limited Warranty 1 Year Limited Warranty 1 Year Limited Warranty
Other Info
  • Upright Design;
  • Does not require pre-freezing;
  • Removable mixing bowl and churn blade;
  • Built-in audible timer;
  • Motor Protection Function that shuts off to prevent damage if the mixture freezes solid;
  • High efficiency CFC-free compressor;
  • ETL Certified
  • Does not require pre-freezing;
  • Removable mixing bowl and churn blade;
  • Built-in audible timer;
  • Motor Protection Function that shuts off to prevent damage if the mixture freezes solid;
  • High efficiency CFC-free compressor;
  • ETL Certified
  • Does not require pre-freezing;
  • Removable mixing bowl and churn blade;
  • Built-in audible timer;
  • Motor Protection Function that shuts off to prevent damage if the mixture freezes solid;
  • High efficiency CFC-free compressor;
  • ETL Certified

You can download manuals from Whynter official site to learn more:
ICM-201SB Manual; ICM-200LS Manual; ICM-15LS Manual

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *